How Globalisation and Competition Policy Inhibit Poverty Reduction: the Case of the South African Wine Industry
نویسنده
چکیده
After more than a decade of deregulation and incorporation into global markets, access to the South African wine industry and ‘empowerment’ remain difficult. The government’s land reform policy notwithstanding, it is very difficult to gain entry into the industry, especially on the upstream side. Given the capital, technology and knowledge intensity of the industry, it is not easy to establish new farmers on the basis of a market driven land reform policy. As the recent KWV ‘Black Economic Empowerment’ (BEE) deal has demonstrated, it is easier to create equity on the downstream side. Stiff competition has followed in the wake of deregulation, both in the domestic and in international markets. This has created ‘winners’ and ‘losers’ at the grower and cellar level – especially in the cooperative sector. Those who have ‘missed’ the transition and are unable to produce grapes/wine for the premium market face the danger of bankruptcy or mergers. Market pressures and stringent supermarket standards are exacerbated by government attempts to regulate employment conditions, tenure arrangements and labour relations in agriculture. For many farmers the combined effect has meant an increase in labour cost, to which they have responded in a variety of ways. Although aggregate employment in the wine industry may have increased, the general trend is towards the downsizing of the permanent on-farm labour force and the increasing use of casual and contract labour instead. The latter are much worse off than the former, having no secure employment or share in the fringe benefits provided by the farmer. The winners amongst labour are the permanent workers who have managed to retain their jobs on the farm. As part of the ‘core’, they have access to reasonable housing, earn the statutory minimum wage and become the recipients of new skills deemed necessary in the ‘quality era’ of the wine industry.
منابع مشابه
Fiscal Policy and Poverty Reduction in Some Selected Sub-Saharan Africa Countries
The equally uncharacterized nature of government role in Sub Saharan African (SSA) region on the issue of poverty reduction have surged the modest research of this study. The issue on poverty is a continuous cause and need remedies so much and fast. This study examined the effect of fiscal policy on poverty reduction in Sub-Saharan Africa from 1999 to 2016. Pool Mean Group (PMG) was employed to...
متن کاملAdjusting to trade liberalisation: the case of firms in the South African textile sector
1 This paper has been prepared as part of the project 'Globalisation, Production and Poverty', financed by a research grant from the UK Department for International Development. South Africa is one of two target countries in which the impact of globalisation is being studied in relation to the textiles industry; the other is Vietnam. For more information on the project, see: www.gapresearch.org...
متن کاملAn Economic Success Story?
The paper provides an evaluation of the development of the South African economy since the end of apartheid in 1994. Taking the 1993 situation as the point of departure, it gives an account of the path leading to the formulation of the major policy documents, and examines to what extent their objectives have been met. It highlights poverty reduction and redistribution, stabilization (fiscal and...
متن کاملThe Rationale for Competition Policy: a South African Perspective
When South Africa made the political transition to a democracy in 1994, the new government inherited an economy characterized by racial inequality, an uncompetitive manufacturing sector and high concentration levels. Within the setting of the democracy, these problems have to be addressed urgently to ensure that all South Africans have equal opportunities to participate in the formal economy. T...
متن کامل